Primary Sources: Hearing It First-Hand
There's a game called "Chinese Whispers" where a message gets distorted as it passes from person to person. History works the same way. The further you are from the original event, the more distorted the account becomes.
That's why historians value primary sources — first-hand accounts from people who were actually there.
Primary vs Secondary vs Tertiary
Primary Sources
Created at the time of the event by someone who was there: diaries, letters, photographs, official documents, treaties, speeches, artefacts, oral testimony.
Example: A letter written by a convict on the First Fleet describing their arrival at Sydney Cove in 1788.
Secondary Sources
Created later by someone who studied the primary sources: history books, documentaries, academic articles, biographies.
Example: A 2020 book about the First Fleet based on letters, diaries, and official records.
Tertiary Sources
Summaries of secondary sources: encyclopedias, textbooks, Wikipedia.
Example: A school textbook paragraph about the First Fleet.
Why Primary Sources Matter
Each step away from the original adds interpretation, selection, and potential bias. A primary source gives you the raw material to form your own interpretation.
But primary sources have limitations too:
- The writer had their own biases
- They only saw part of the event
- They might be lying, exaggerating, or misremembering
- Not all people could write — so written records exclude illiterate voices
Australian Primary Sources You Can Access
- Trove: Millions of digitised Australian newspapers, photos, and documents (free)
- National Archives of Australia: Government records, immigration files, military records
- AIATSIS: Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies — oral histories and cultural records
- State libraries: Each state holds unique collections of diaries, maps, and photographs
Tonight's Question
"If someone 200 years from now wanted to understand our family, what primary sources would they find? What would those sources get wrong about us?"
Think about: social media posts, text messages, school reports, photos. Do they tell the real story?
Family Primary Source Investigation
- Find a primary source from your family's history: an old letter, photo, document, recipe, or object.
- If you don't have one, interview a grandparent or older relative. Record the conversation — you're creating a primary source!
- Analyse your source: what does it tell you? What doesn't it tell you?
- Write a short "secondary source" — a paragraph describing what you learned.
- Compare: how much was lost between the primary source and your summary?
Go Further
- Website: National Archives of Australia (naa.gov.au) — search historical records, including your own family's immigration or military records.
- AIATSIS: aiatsis.gov.au — access Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander primary sources.
- Challenge: Find a primary source and a secondary source about the same event. What did the secondary source change, add, or leave out?
- Question: Are social media posts primary sources? Will historians use TikTok videos to study the 2020s?
What We Simplified
- The primary/secondary distinction isn't always clear. A newspaper article written during an event is primary, but it's also an interpretation.
- Oral traditions are primary sources. Aboriginal oral histories, passed down for thousands of years, are legitimate primary sources, even though they're not written.
- Wikipedia can be useful. While it's a tertiary source, its citations often lead to excellent primary and secondary sources.
Sources
- National Archives of Australia. naa.gov.au
- AIATSIS. aiatsis.gov.au
- Tosh, J. (2015). The Pursuit of History. 6th ed. Routledge.
- Howell, M. & Prevenier, W. (2001). From Reliable Sources: An Introduction to Historical Methods. Cornell University Press.
Want to track progress and save lessons?
Create a free family account. No credit card, no catch — just a place to keep track of what your family is learning.
Create Free Account