Skip to content
How Systems Work

Alternative Schools That Already Exist

Ages 12–16 25 min read Intermediate

The mainstream school model isn't the only option. Around the world — and in Australia — alternative education models have been proving for decades that children can learn powerfully without rows, bells, and standardised tests.

Major Alternative Models

Montessori

Developed by Maria Montessori (Italy, 1907). Key features:

  • Mixed-age classrooms (3-year age spans)
  • Student-directed learning — children choose their activities
  • No grades or tests — progress is observed and documented
  • Specially designed materials that teach through manipulation

Research shows Montessori students score as well as or better than conventional students on academic measures, and significantly better on creativity and social skills (Lillard, 2012).

Steiner/Waldorf

Developed by Rudolf Steiner (Germany, 1919). Key features:

  • No formal academics before age 7 — focus on play and imagination
  • Arts integrated into every subject
  • No screens or digital technology in early years
  • Same teacher stays with a class for multiple years

Democratic Schools

Students and staff have equal votes on school rules, curriculum, and decisions. The most famous is Summerhill (UK, founded 1921). In Australia, examples include Currambena in Sydney.

Unschooling/Self-Directed Learning

No set curriculum. Children follow their interests with adult support. Pioneered by John Holt (1970s). Legal in all Australian states with registration requirements.

Homeschooling

Parent-directed education at home. Growing rapidly in Australia — approximately 30,000 registered homeschoolers (2023), with the real number likely higher. The COVID-19 pandemic sparked significant growth.

What the Research Shows

A comprehensive review by Gray and Riley (2015) of unschooled children found they went on to successful careers across all fields. The key factor was not the method of education but the quality of engagement — children who were actively supported in their interests thrived regardless of the model.

Tonight's Question

"If you could attend any type of school — conventional, Montessori, Steiner, democratic, or home-based — which would you choose? Why?"

School Model Comparison

  1. Each family member researches one alternative education model.
  2. Present: how does it work? What are the pros and cons?
  3. Compare to the current school experience.
  4. Discuss: which elements from alternative models could be adopted at home, regardless of where you go to school?
  5. Pick one element to try: e.g., student-directed learning for a Saturday afternoon, a Montessori-style practical skills session, a democratic family meeting.

Go Further

  • Visit: If possible, arrange to visit a local Montessori, Steiner, or alternative school (many hold open days).
  • Book: Free to Learn by Peter Gray (2013) — the case for self-directed education.
  • Research: Homeschooling laws in your Australian state/territory. What are the requirements?
  • Question: Can the best elements of alternative education be brought into mainstream schools?

What We Simplified

  • Alternative models have weaknesses too. Montessori can lack structure for children who need it. Unschooling requires highly engaged parents. Democratic schools can be chaotic.
  • Socioeconomic factors matter. Many alternative schools are private and expensive. The families who can access them are often already privileged.
  • Mainstream schools serve most children well. For the majority of families, the local public school provides a solid education. Reform within the system may be more impactful than alternatives outside it.

Sources

  • Lillard, A.S. (2012). "Preschool children's development in classic Montessori, supplemented Montessori, and conventional programs." Journal of School Psychology, 50(3), 379-401.
  • Gray, P. & Riley, G. (2015). "Grown Unschoolers' Evaluations of Their Unschooling Experiences." Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning, 9(18), 1-33.
  • Holt, J. (1967). How Children Learn. Pitman.

Want to track progress and save lessons?

Create a free family account. No credit card, no catch — just a place to keep track of what your family is learning.

Create Free Account